Embryonic stem-cell research has returned to the forefront of political discourse as candidates posture for November elections. In a decision on Aug. 23, a United States of America district judge reinstated prohibitions on embryonic stem-cell research. President Obama signed an executive order releasing federal funds for stem cell research shortly after his inauguration. A pair of science researchers backed by religious groups sued to overturn that order. Obama’s executive order overturned a ban imposed by George W. Bush in 2001. The judge cast a pall over research being conducted on diseases like diabetes, Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s. Scientists, as a group, are appalled. An appeal strategy is being formulated by the administration. The political utility of the stem cell issue is being evaluated by both parties.
Faith comes out above science with stem cell determination
A judge’s decision to renew the ban on federally funded embryonic stem cell research caught the scientific community by surprise. The suit was brought by Nightlight Christian Adoptions and other religious organizations. Scientists involved in the complaint claimed discrimination. They convinced the judge that researchers using adult stem-cells facing competition for federal aid from embryonic embryo programs is unfair. In an article published by U.S. News and World Report, a scientist said embryo suffered a 10-year setback with the ruling. Susan Solomon, CEO of the New York Stem Cell Foundation, told United States of America News the court final decision “allows a vocal minority to hold scientific disciplines hostage to a narrow political agenda”.
Politicians consider usage of stem cell ruling
An appeal by the Justice Department on the court finding is inevitable. Wall Street Journal coverage notes that other means of funding embryonic stem cell research are being investigated by advocates of the practice. The potential payoff is being weighed by political strategists. A Republican strategist told the Journal that stem cell research may help motivate loyal anti-abortion voters, however jobs will get more attention. The issue could help Democrats, because embryonic stem-cell research is supported by a majority of Americans. The stem cell dustup might help President Obama as he works to frame the midterm elections as a choice between moving the country forward or in reverse.
The lawful status associated with stem cell research
The Justice Department said the administration would ask the district court to put its ruling on hold while the appeals court considers the issue. Marco Bolo, commenting on the article in U.S. News, pointed out a 1996 law restricting the usage of federal funds for embryonic embryo research. Bolo contends that Obama cannot overturn existing legislation and the judge is simply enforcing the regulation. To ensure that embryonic stem cell research continues is simple. The law must be changed.
Discover more data on this subject
U.S. News and World Report
health.usnews.com
Wall Street Journal
wsj.com
